To the Editor: Lamberth raised some worthwhile issues about small-ship adventure tourism to Antarctica in his recent case report describing the death of an 82-year-old tourist.1 This occurred in 1999, the season I started as medical director for the leading polar adventure tour company that chartered the vessel involved. I have some comments and an update.

The former Soviet oceanographic research vessel was converted in the 1990s to carry 78 passengers. She had a two-bed infirmary and a procedure room with Russian and German medical supplies for passengers and crew, and carried a German- and English-speaking Russian doctor experienced with passenger ship medicine. The tour operator provided additional medical supplies and an emergency physician. Ventilatory support could have been provided, although not to the standard of a contemporary Australian intensive care unit. Polar adventure operations are very different from "tropical" cruise lines, which generally operate their own ships from home ports and cater for up to 3000 passengers with very different expectations.2

Operators require that prospective passengers submit a medical information form and a declaration from their personal physician that they are fit for the journey. The 82-year-old who died was a retired physician who did not declare the extent of his limitations, and who acted as his own medical advisor. His is the only death I am aware of after seven years' involvement in the industry.

The medical declaration form has been modified and now addresses the risk factors identified by Lamberth. Prospective clients with questionable health are referred to the medical director. However, operators cannot verify declarations of good health, and physicians have been known to collude with passengers to avoid risk of rejection.

Furthermore, "ageism" is as unacceptable as sexism and racism. I was present on the first passenger-circumnavigation of Antarctica in the company of several octogenarians and a 90-year-old, and on the first circumnavigation of the Arctic Ocean, with other octogenarians and a 92-year-old. Short trips to the Antarctic Peninsula are very different from scientific expeditions; Lamberth's suggestion that advising doctors should consider scientific expedition criteria is inappropriate.

The International Association of Antarctic Tour Operators (<www.iaato.org>) is a voluntary association of competing adventure eco-tour operators whose purpose is to self-regulate the industry and to develop good standards. Standards for provision of medical supplies and capabilities are under development by this association.